“The Submissive Female Fantasy: Why EL James, Bella Swan,
and Newsweek Can (get on their knees and) Suck Me”
By Lilith Duvalier
“She can enjoy his punishments and leather whips and mild
humiliations without ever having to say that she sought them out or chose them.
It’s not that she wants to be whipped, it’s that she willingly endures it out
of love for, and maybe in effort to save, a handsome man. This little trick of
the mind, of course, is one of the central aspects of sexual submission: you
can experience it without claiming responsibility, without committing to
actually wanting it, which has a natural appeal to both our puritan past and
our post ironic present.”
- The Fantasy Life of
Working Women: Why Surrender is a Feminist Dream by Katie Roiphe, Newsweek.
Let me start with a few caveats:
1. It is obviously
counterproductive to get prescriptive about people’s sexual fantasies if no one
is getting hurt.
2. Stephanie Meyers is
an uneducated hack who stumbled into a formula.
3. I haven’t read “50
Shades of Grey” and I’m not going to, cause fuck it that’s why.
4. Fuck the
expectation of “Different Strokes” and “Judge Not” and “Don’t Make Waves” that
as a “nice young lady” I’m supposed to adhere to-
While I understand BDSM games and
the appeal of spicing things up in the bedroom, even in a somewhat extreme way
and even on a fairly regular basis if that sort of thing flips your skirt- I
think that the 24/7 “lifestyle” thing is fucked. I think it’s abuse with
accessories, and I think agreeing to that sort of thing (contract be damned) is
Quiet Suburban Stockholm Syndrome. I’d let a guy tie me up, but if suggested a
collar he’d come home to find the locks changed and all his shit in the front
lawn. On fire. (What do you think about humiliation now, baby? Cause the
neighbors sure are getting a kick out of it.)
Anyway. Welcome to my blog and here is some more of
my opinion-
I am exactly the “ambitious, liberal arts graduate” that
this article gently mocks, and all I want is a “nice, postfeminist boy.” My
ideal husband is somewhere on the spectrum between Xander Harris and Phil
Dunphy. Love, respect, some ability to
kick ass buried down in there somewhere, and a sense of humor. That’s the
dream.
I’m also an erotica author, and you couldn’t tell by what I
personally write, but I have my thumb pretty well on the pulse of what sells.
It’s this.
It’s the female character who swears just enough to make you
think that she’s spunky, but doesn’t do enough to make you believe that she’s
capable, submitting to the tall dark and handsome dominant man who swashbuckles
his way into her life, sometimes actually, genuinely holding his huge (phallic)
sword out at her. Or worse, brooding in his Volvo at her.
And it bothers me.
Because, as is the point of Ms. Roiphe’s thorough and
respectful, though not terribly insightful, article: women are more powerful
than men these days. They make up 60% of college graduates, four in ten working
women out earn their husbands, the majority of women under 30 are having and
supporting their own children, and they still have this fantasy of a dominant
man.
And just to rub salt in the wound there are articles like
this one speculating on whether that desire is, in some primal way, ingrained
in the mysterious female psyche, or if submission is a relaxing past time for
someone with too much control in the “real world”, or that assuming that it’s
an outlet for the guilt, shame and unworthiness that must be ingrained in women
is too 19th century an explanation for why this phenomena persists.
And it’s just frustrating on so many levels.
One: Of Course Guilt,
Shame and Unworthiness Persist, dumbass.
Most of the magazines at the grocery store are just long
lists of how women do everything from eating to dressing to having sex wrong
anyway. There is an attack on women’s healthcare happening all over our country
because men want to punish women for having sex. Every horror movie has its
dead slut in the first hour. And that’s not even counting all the little things
that get so ingrained that you forget about them.
One of the best examples I’ve found explaining this idea is
actually a cracked article, but it’s still a depressing and hysterical
illustration.
And look at the way the media forces us to look at
ourselves. Look at Michelle Bachman and Sarah Palin and then try to pretend we
live in a post-feminist society. Their media coverage was a constant barrage and
they aren’t politicians, they’re clowns. Dolls, more accurately. Pretty enough
women with pretty enough clothes, talking for the cameras.
Media coverage on Hillary Clinton usually mocked her looks
or harrased her for being a ballbuster.
You can be a politician ladies, but only if you’re
entertaining. If you’re a legitimate threat? Congratulations- You’re a Bitch.
Two: The Whole Idea
of a Sudden Interest in Female Submission Assumes Male Dominance is a Default
Position that Society is In Danger of Losing.
Just… no. The logic string that brings you to this
conclusion starts in the middle of an episode of Madmen. There is nothing
inherently dominant about men. Upper body strength stopped being impressive
when the Industrial Revolution really started to catch on.
There is no reason to want to hold onto an old fashioned
idea that imprisons men as much as it imprisons women. And, lets be totally
honest- an assumption that men will be competent, capable and dominant, makes
them arrogant assholes that are utterly fucking useless. If you read that
Cracked article? The douche who thinks he is owed a woman, does not learn how
to treat one. The jackass who thinks a financial degree entitles him to a six
figure salary, can’t even balance his checkbook without calling his mother.
And I’m not exaggerating. I talk to educated young men all
day, who have honest to god hissy-fits at me because they didn’t get the
awesome suit and tie job they thought was waiting for them.
Yeah, brah, and I went to the College of Phone in South
Cubicle and majored in Getting Screamed At By Filthy Hicks Like You.
No. I’m much
better educated than you, (I have more debt than you and work harder than you
in heels bigger than your dick) and I pay my damn bills while I work for the dream job. Go get your nose wiped and your
shoes tied and then try the big boy thing again.
Three: Good BDSM is
Not About Kink Or Spanking or Violence, Its About Trust.
The arrogant bastard heroes who the examples of this- who
are supposed to be so intoxicatingly sexy because their shoulders are so broad
and their jaws are so square- are assholes.
Edward Cullen is an abusive asshole, constantly threatening
Bella, and it’s her damn fault for smelling so good to start with. That’s a Lifetime
movie waiting to happen.
It's absolutely not something you put up with because he needs to get his Alpha on and can't find it in anyway but taking it out on you. It's not something you endure for him.
You don’t want to try a BDSM game with a jackass.
You know who you want to try it with?
The skinny, nice, post feminist boy who loves you and can be
reliably counted on to spank you and still remember to do the dishes in the
morning.